Saturday, April 21, 2012

Bella as a hero?

Talking in class about this the other day, made me really think on whether or not Bella is considered a hero in my eyes. Of course, we all  know she saves everyone at the end by turning out to be a shield after her change, so yes, I suppose in the loosest sense, she is a hero. But I've always had a major issue with Bella's character to begin with. There were four books that took us through the story: Twilight, New Moon, Eclipse, and Breaking Dawn. Typically all four, in a sense, have Bella's mortal life in danger, with the exception of Breaking Dawn after she was turned, which put her life in danger as an immortal. Though I dislike her character nearly entirely as a whole, Breaking Dawn seems to be where the problems I have with her take a turn towards disdain. In Breaking Dawn, after the birth of Nessie, Bella  is, for lack of a better word, "perfect". She, unlike every other newborn we've heard of up until this point, is not bloodthirsty, she is in complete control of her actions in the hunt and every time else (to the point to where even Carlisle is baffled), and she turns out to be a shield (who can still block Edward if she so desires) at the perfect time where one just happens to be needed to save everyone's lives. I've heard some argue that she's earned this "easy" outcome base on every misfortune she's endured until book four. I simply think it's ridiculous. After those so called frequent misfortunes, it's disappointing to end a book with so much build up, with essentially nothing. Anyone else agree?

3 comments:

  1. I completely agree. There should have been another book in between somewhere that would detail Bella's trials as a newborn so she would have to go through typical newborn hunger. There was so much more that could have been done with this series but it just sort of fell flat to me.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree. Bella in Breaking Dawn after she was turned didn't have any problems at all really. Everything was handed to her, she got to see the baby, and the rest of her family, she didn't have any problems with being hungry or thirsting for thier blood, and to top it off she gets given the shield as another power besides being able to control her hunger. I think she should have had to go through some issues that newborn are faced with not have everything so "easy".

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree as well. I never saw Bella as a hero through any of the books and eventhough she saved everyone in the end did she really? There wasn't even a battle to begin with. Which in my opinion was a total let down. What was all of the build up for if wasn't at least for a fight? I felt like the ending of Breaking Dawn was just abrupt and a let down.

    ReplyDelete